Journal of Intelligent Strategic Management

Journal of Intelligent Strategic Management

The Normative Architecture of Strategic Decisions: A Behavioral–Institutional Framework with Evidence from the Iranian Upstream Oil and Gas Sector

Document Type : Original Article

Authors
1 PhD Student, Department of Financial markets and institutions, Faculty of Management, University of Tehran, Tehran, Iran.
2 Professor, Department of Financial markets and institutions, Faculty of Management, University of Tehran, Tehran, Iran.
3 Professor, Department of Financial engineering, Faculty of Management, University of Tehran, Tehran, Iran.
Abstract
Mechanism design, the engineering branch of game theory, rests on a foundational premise: arrange the payoffs correctly and the rational agent will select the action the designer intends. That premise is the explicit operating logic of Iran's new-generation petroleum contracts, and more generally of decision architecture in large state-linked organizations. This paper addresses a strategic question: when an engineered incentive not only fails to work but drives behavior in the direction opposite to its intent, where in the design chain has the failure occurred? Rather than adding a further catalogue of behavioral biases, the paper locates the failure in a constraint that standard mechanism design leaves implicit.
The study is a conceptual–integrative paper employing abductive reasoning: it moves from a set of observations to the most parsimonious generative structure that would render them expected, and then converts that structure into falsifiable propositions. The anomalies come from semi-structured interviews with 10 industry experts, and which were translated into an experiment design with 68 graduate participants (34 employer–contractor dyads) playing nine incentivized, industry-framed economic games with real monetary payoffs at the Behavioral Economics Laboratory, Faculty of Management, University of Tehran. The full statistical treatment of each anomaly is reported in companion papers; here the evidence functions as the explanandum, not as a finding claimed by this paper. Because abduction establishes only the best available explanation, a dedicated section evaluates four rival accounts - comprehension failure, experimenter demand, risk preference, and measurement ceiling - and shows that none reproduces the full observed pattern.
Three anomalies that appear distinct are argued to be one phenomenon. The alignment paradox: the 5% stake raised delegation from 51. 5% to 91%, precisely against the strategy it had made dominant, and the switching was strongly asymmetric (94% versus 11%) , a directional signature that random misunderstanding cannot produce. The quality ceiling: 94. 1% invested in high quality irrespective of contract type, with 85. 3% within-subject consistency. The asymmetric cooperation pattern: dictator offers averaged 37. 3% against a 28. 3% benchmark with zero-offers entirely absent, yet ultimatum offers (35. 2%) did not exceed their own benchmark, generosity appeared precisely where strategy did not compel it, which is a prediction of the framework rather than an exception to it. The proposed framework, normative override, posits a two-stage choice architecture in which Stage 2, the consequentialist payoff comparison the standard model assumes, is reached only when Stag-1 norm retrieval is weak or contested and the decision-maker has both the cognitive capacity and the psychological safety to get there. Four propositions follow: norm primacy, perverse alignment, cognitive gating, and hierarchy/psychological-safety moderation.
The central theoretical implication is stated as a constraint. In norm-governed populations, incentive compatibility and individual rationality are not jointly sufficient for implementation; a mechanism must additionally satisfy what we term the norm-compatibility constraint: the designer's target action must lie within the norm-permissible action set. Where it does not, no transfer implements it, and raising the transfer can push the target action further outside that set — which is the alignment paradox. The standard model is the special case in which the full action set coincides with normative -compatible set, so the claim delimits rather than refutes it. The practical ordering of intervention inverts: legitimize the action first, then tune the payoffs. Five boundary tests are specified, one testable on data already in hand.
Keywords
Subjects

دادگر، یدالله.  ۱۳۹۶.  الگوهای اقتصاد رفتاری و ظرفیت اصلاح رویکرد حاکم.  اقتصاد تطبیقی، ۶۹–۸۸.
سالاری، مصطفی؛ مفیدیان، شراره.  ۱۳۹۳.  بررسی حقوقی امکان به‌کارگیری روش قراردادی ساخت، بهره‌برداری و واگذاری در صنعت نفت ایران.  بررسی‌های بازرگانی، ۱۲۶۴، ۲۹–۴۳.
شهبازپور، نسرین؛ مرادی، محسن؛ میرعباسی، سید باقر.  ۱۴۰۳.  ساختار حقوقی قراردادهای جدید نفتی ایران (IPC).  تحولات اجتماعی–سیاسی معاصر ایران، ۳۲، ۳۴۶–۳۶۷.
کاتوزیان، محمدعلی همایون.  ۱۳۹۳.  ایران، جامعه کوتاه‌مدت.  تهران:  نشر نی.
محمودی، وحید؛ بهشتی، علی.  ۱۳۹۸ عقلانیت و آزادی.  تهران:  نشر نی.
واعظی، سید کمال؛ شیرانی فرادنبه، آرش.  ۱۴۰۴شناسایی سوگیری‌ها و تلنگرهای رفتاری در مدیریت بحران.  پژوهش‌های مدیریت عمومی، ۱۸۶۹، ۱۵۵–۱۸۸.
Aghlimoghadam, L. (2025). New-institutional explanations for energy transition in Iran: investigating the interplays between institutions, actors, and technology. Innovation: The European Journal of Social Science Research, 38(2), 934–960.
Akerlof, G.  A. , & Kranton, R.  E.  (2005).  Identity and the economics of organizations.  Journal of Economic Perspectives, 19(1), 9–32.
Akerlof, G.  A. , & Kranton, R.  E.  (2010).  Identity economics:  How our identities shape our work, wages, and well،being.  Princeton University Press.
Anderson, C.  J.  (2003).  The psychology of doing nothing:  Forms of decision avoidance result from reason and emotion.  Psychological Bulletin, 129(1), 139–167.
Audia, P.  G. , Gigerenzer, G. , Hodgkinson, G.  P. , Levinthal, D. , & Liu, C.  (2025).  Bounded rationality and decision making in organizations:  The way forward.  Academy of Management Proceedings.
Bartling, B. , & Fischbacher, U.  (2012).  Shifting the blame:  On delegation and responsibility.  The Review of Economic Studies, 79(1), 67–87.
Beeman, W.  O.  (1986).  Language, status, and power in Iran.  Bloomington:  Indiana University Press.
Bicchieri, C.  (2006).  The grammar of society:  The nature and dynamics of social norms.  Cambridge University Press.
Blunden, H. , Logg, J.  M. , Brooks, A.  W. , John, L.  K. , & Gino, F.  (2023).  Seeking advice from the crowd:  Responsibility diffusion in the wisdom of crowds.  Journal of Behavioral Decision Making, 36(1), e2265.
Bowles, S. , & Polanía،Reyes, S.  (2012).  Economic incentives and social preferences:  Substitutes or complements? Journal of Economic Literature, 50(2), 368–425.
Camerer, C.  F.  (2003).  Behavioral game theory:  Experiments in strategic interaction.  Princeton University Press.
Camerer, C.  F. , & Hogarth, R.  M.  (1999).  The effects of financial incentives in experiments:  A review and capital،labor،production framework.  Journal of Risk and Uncertainty, 19(1), 7–42.
Camerer, C.  F. , Dreber, A. , Forsell, E. , Ho, T. ،H. , Huber, J. , Johannesson, M. , et al.  (2016).  Evaluating replicability of laboratory experiments in economics.  Science, 351(6280), 1433–1436.
Csaszar, F.  A. , Hannigan, T.  R. , & Pemer, F.  (2024).  Bounded rationality and organizational routines:  A reappraisal.  Strategic Management Journal.
Edmondson, A.  (1999).  Psychological safety and learning behavior in work teams.  Administrative Science Quarterly, 44(2), 350–383.
Engel, C.  (2011).  Dictator games:  A meta study.  Experimental Economics, 14(4), 583–610.
Evans, J.  S.  B.  T. , & Stanovich, K.  E.  (2013).  Dual،process theories of higher cognition:  Advancing the debate.  Perspectives on Psychological Science, 8(3), 223–241.
Fehr, E. , Klein, A. , & Schmidt, K.  M.  (2007).  Fairness and contract design.  Econometrica, 75(1), 121–154.
Frederick, S.  (2005).  Cognitive reflection and decision making.  Journal of Economic Perspectives, 19(4), 25–42.
Frey, B.  S. , & Jegen, R.  (2001).  Motivation crowding theory.  Journal of Economic Surveys, 15(5), 589–611.
Ghandi, A. , & Lin, C. ،Y.  C.  (2014).  Oil and gas service contracts around the world:  A review.  Energy Strategy Reviews, 3, 63–71.
Gneezy, U. , & Rustichini, A.  (2000).  A fine is a price.  Journal of Legal Studies, 29(1), 1–17.
Hamman, J.  R. , Loewenstein, G. , & Weber, R.  A.  (2010).  Self،interest through delegation:  An additional rationale for the principal،agent relationship.  American Economic Review, 100(4), 1826–1846.
Holmström, B. , & Milgrom, P.  (1991).  Multitask principal،agent analyses:  Incentive contracts, asset ownership, and job design.  Journal of Law, Economics, and Organization, 7(special), 24–52.
House, R.  J. , Hanges, P.  J. , Javidan, M. , Dorfman, P.  W. , & Gupta, V.  (Eds. ).  (2004).  Culture, leadership, and organizations:  The GLOBE study of 62 societies.  Thousand Oaks, CA:  Sage.
Hurwicz, L. , & Reiter, S.  (2006).  Designing economic mechanisms.  Cambridge University Press.
Javidan, M. , & Dastmalchian, A.  (2003).  Culture and leadership in Iran:  The land of individual achievers, strong family ties, and powerful elite.  Academy of Management Executive, 17(4), 127–142.
Johnson, N.  D. , & Mislin, A.  A.  (2011).  Trust games:  A meta،analysis.  Journal of Economic Psychology, 32(5), 865–889.
Kahneman, D.  (2011).  Thinking, fast and slow.  Farrar, Straus and Giroux.
Kahneman, D. , & Tversky, A.  (1979).  Prospect theory:  An analysis of decision under risk.  Econometrica, 47(2), 263–291.
Kerrissey, M.  J. , Edmondson, A.  C. , & Bahadurzada, H.  (2024).  Psychological safety, employee burnout and turnover during the COVID،19 pandemic.  International Journal of Public Health, 69.
Konstantinidis, A.  D.  (2024).  The cognitive reflection test and investment decision.  IOSR Journal of Economics and Finance, 15(5), 1–3.
Kőszegi, B.  (2014).  Behavioral contract theory.  Journal of Economic Literature, 52(4), 1075–1118.
Krupka, E.  L. , & Weber, R.  A.  (2013).  Identifying social norms using coordination games:  Why does dictator game sharing vary? Journal of the European Economic Association, 11(3), 495–524.
Luce, R.  D. , & Raiffa, H.  (1957).  Games and decisions:  Introduction and critical survey.  New York:  Wiley.
March, J.  G. , & Olsen, J.  P.  (2011).  The logic of appropriateness.  In R.  E.  Goodin (Ed. ), The Oxford handbook of political science.  Oxford University Press.
Maskin, E.  (1999).  Nash equilibrium and welfare optimality.  The Review of Economic Studies, 66(1), 23–38.
Meyer, A. , Kahneman, D. , Frederick, S. , Bar،Hillel, M. , & Attali, Y.  (2024).  Cognitive reflection is a distinct and measurable trait.  Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences, 121(49), e2409191121.
Myerson, R.  B.  (1981).  Optimal auction design.  Mathematics of Operations Research, 6(1), 58–73.
Oosterbeek, H. , Sloof, R. , & van de Kuilen, G.  (2004).  Cultural differences in ultimatum game experiments:  Evidence from a meta،analysis.  Experimental Economics, 7(2), 171–188.
Savage, L.  J.  (1954).  The foundations of statistics.  New York:  Wiley.
Simon, H.  A.  (1955).  A behavioral model of rational choice.  Quarterly Journal of Economics, 69(1), 99–118.
Soleimani, M. , & Tavakolian, M.  (2017).  Comparative financial analysis of IPC, the new Iran's oil fields development and production enhancement framework:  IPC vs.  buyback contracts.  SPE Symposium:  Production Enhancement and Cost Optimisation, Kuala Lumpur, Malaysia.
Spadaro, G. , Jin, S. , & Balliet, D.  (2022).  Gender differences in cooperation across 20 societies:  A meta،analysis.  Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society B, 377(1868), 20210438.
Thornton, P.  H. , Ocasio, W. , & Lounsbury, M.  (2012).  The institutional logics perspective.  Oxford University Press.
Tirole, J.  (1999).  Incomplete contracts:  Where do we stand? Econometrica, 67(4), 741–781.
Tversky, A. , & Kahneman, D.  (1991).  Loss aversion in riskless choice:  A reference،dependent model.  Quarterly Journal of Economics, 106(4), 1039–1061.

Articles in Press, Accepted Manuscript
Available Online from 18 August 2026